Shelter Island, NY, USA to Montauk, NY, USA from $13: 3 ways by bus, train, flight or car

Compare Travel Options and Prices

How to Get from Shelter Island to Montauk: Cheapest, Fastest and Best Way

1Map provides directions to cities, towns, landmarks, attractions, and addresses worldwide, offering thousands of multi-modal routes to easily get you from point A to point B.

$13 by busBest price

34 kmDistance

47m Fastest

Compare Train, Bus, Flight, and Driving Options

Get detailed, step-by-step directions below for your trip from Shelter Island to Montauk with 1Map travel planner. Easily compare ticket prices, explore various transport options, and find the best routes for a seamless and cost-effective travel experience.

See more options

Sort by

Browse car rentals Explore flights

Traveling From Shelter Island to Montauk

This route takes you from the tranquil charm of Shelter Island to the vibrant beach culture of Montauk, offering an exciting contrast between serene island life and a bustling coastal atmosphere.

Best Neighbourhoods in Montauk

Montauk offers diverse neighborhoods, each with its own distinct vibe and attractions.

Downtown Montauk

• Lively restaurants and shops within walking distance.

• Close proximity to the iconic Montauk Lighthouse.

Ditch Plain

• Known for its excellent surfing conditions.

• Scenic beach views and relaxed atmosphere.

Montauk Point

• Home to breathtaking coastal cliffs and trails.

• Offers stunning sunsets and rich wildlife.

Best Times To Visit Montauk's Attractions

Timing your visit can greatly enhance your experience in Montauk.

Montauk Lighthouse

Visit early in the morning for fewer crowds and stunning sunrise views.

Ditch Plain Beach

Weekdays during late spring provide warm weather and less foot traffic.

Fort Pond

Late afternoon is ideal for a peaceful atmosphere and beautiful sunsets.

Montauk Weather: What to Expect Year-Round

Montauk experiences a coastal climate with warm summers and chilly winters, making late spring and early fall the best times to visit for pleasant weather. Understanding the local weather patterns can help you plan activities and pack accordingly for an enjoyable trip.

Dining Recommendation in Montauk

Try the fresh seafood tacos at the popular eatery, The Dock, where the lively atmosphere and local ingredients create a vibrant dining experience unique to Montauk. This contrasts with the more laid-back, seasonal offerings found on Shelter Island, bringing a burst of bold flavors and beachside energy.

Shelter Island - Montauk operators

Explore transport companies operating between Shelter Island and Montauk, with prices starting at . These companies offer competitive pricing, flexible schedules, and comfortable travel experiences.

Bus

Contact phone

+1 212.362.8400

Website

https://www.hamptonjitney.com

Bus from Sag Harbor-Eastbound to Montauk

Average Duration

38m

Estimated price

$13-27

Train

Contact phone

+1-718-217-5477

Website

https://new.mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road

Train from Bridgehampton to Montauk

Average Duration

35m

Estimated price

$3-14

Shelter Island to Montauk: Overview of Bus, Train, Flight, and Car Trips

Traveling between Shelter Island and Montauk offers a variety of convenient options to suit your preferences, schedule, and budget. Whether you prioritize affordability, speed, or comfort, you’re sure to find the perfect way to travel without compromising on quality or convenience.

🚆 Experience a scenic journey from Shelter Island to Montauk by train, which takes approximately 2 hours and includes stunning views along the way.

💸 Prices for the bus ride from Montauk to Shelter Island range from $13 to $27, offering an affordable and convenient travel option for those looking to explore the East End of Long Island. With various fare options available, you can choose the best one that suits your budget and travel plans.

Frequently asked questions

Find out more about the route from Shelter Island to Montauk.

Or choose the category:

The distance between Shelter Island and Montauk is approximately 21 miles. The typical travel time by bus from Shelter Island to Montauk is 2 hours and 13 minutes. Other modes of transportation, such as driving or taking a taxi, may have slightly shorter travel times depending on traffic conditions.

The most cost-effective and time-efficient transportation option for traveling from Shelter Island to Montauk is by bus. The bus takes approximately 2 hours and 13 minutes and costs $6. This is both the cheapest and fastest way to reach Montauk from Shelter Island. Other modes of transportation may be more expensive or take longer travel times, making the bus the preferred choice for budget-conscious and time-sensitive travelers.

The price for a bus ride between Shelter Island and Montauk is $5. This is a convenient and affordable option for travelers looking to explore both destinations. By choosing the bus, you can enjoy a comfortable journey while saving money compared to other modes of transportation. Whether you are visiting for a day trip or planning a longer stay, the bus is a popular choice among travelers for its cost-effectiveness.

To travel from Shelter Island to Montauk without a car, the best option is to take the bus. The bus journey takes approximately 2 hours and 13 minutes and costs around $6. This is a convenient and affordable mode of transportation for those who do not have access to a car. Along the way, travelers can enjoy the scenic views of the surrounding areas before reaching their destination in Montauk.

There are several options for accommodation near Montauk. With 106+ hotels available, travelers have a variety of choices to suit their preferences and budget. Prices for hotels in the area start at $88 per night. It is recommended to check for availability and make reservations in advance, especially during peak travel seasons.

Yes, you can get from Shelter Island to Montauk by bicycle. The distance between the two locations is 21 miles, and the typical travel time by bike is around 1.5 to 2 hours. The route usually follows scenic roads, including the Shelter Island Ferry and traveling through scenic areas of the Hamptons before reaching Montauk. Biking allows you to enjoy the beautiful surroundings while getting some exercise and experiencing the journey at your own pace.