Montauk, NY, USA to Fishers Island, NY, USA from $55: 4 ways by bus, train, flight or car

The distance between Montauk and Fishers Island is approximately 40 miles, typically requiring a ferry ride. Traveling by car to the nearest ferry terminal takes about 30-40 minutes, followed by a ferry ride that lasts around 30-45 minutes. Alternatively, a private boat can cover the distance in about 1 hour, depending on the speed and conditions. Overall, the entire journey can take anywhere from 1 to 2 hours based on wait times and transportation options.

The most cost-effective and time-efficient transportation option from Montauk to Fishers Island is to drive to the nearest ferry terminal in New London, Connecticut, and take the ferry. This route typically costs less than private boating options and saves time compared to arranging a charter. The ferry ride itself is relatively quick, taking around 30-45 minutes. Overall, this method balances both cost and efficiency, making it ideal for travelers.

Traveling from Montauk to Fishers Island typically involves ferry fees, which can range from $20 to $30 per person for a round trip, depending on the ferry service. If you're driving to a ferry terminal, there may also be parking fees, which can vary but generally cost around $15 to $30 per day. For those considering a private boat, costs can vary significantly based on the rental service and fuel prices, usually amounting to over $100. Overall, travelers should budget accordingly based on their chosen mode of transportation.

To travel from Montauk to Fishers Island without using public transportation, you can drive to a nearby ferry terminal, such as in New London, CT. From there, you can take a private boat or yacht, which can be rented or borrowed from local marinas. Alternatively, you might arrange for a water taxi service to take you directly to Fishers Island. Another option is to charter a private helicopter or seaplane, offering a more adventurous but costlier journey.

To travel from Montauk to Fishers Island without a car, you can start by using a bicycle or walking to the nearest ferry terminal at New London, CT, which is approximately a 40-minute drive away. Consider using a rideshare service or taxi to reach the terminal. Once at New London, you can take a ferry directly to Fishers Island, or arrange for a water taxi or private boat service. Additionally, you could explore bike rentals in Montauk for a scenic ride to your destination.

There is no direct ferry service between Montauk and Fishers Island. Travelers typically need to take a ferry from Montauk to either New London or Point Judith, and then transfer to another ferry that goes to Fishers Island. This multi-step journey can take some time, so it's essential to check the schedules for both ferry routes in advance. Planning ahead will help ensure a smooth transfer between the different ferry services.

There are no commercial flights directly between Montauk and Fishers Island due to the short distance involved. A helicopter or private flight could cover the distance in approximately 15-20 minutes, but this option is generally not cost-effective for most travelers. Helicopter charters can vary widely in price, typically ranging from $1000 to $2500 per hour, depending on the service provider. As a result, many visitors opt for ferry services or private boats for their journeys between the two locations.

Near Fishers Island accommodations are somewhat limited, but there are a few charming options available. The Fishers Island Inn offers a historic and cozy stay with beautiful views, while private rental homes and cottages can be found through platforms like Airbnb. For a more luxurious experience, consider looking into yacht charters that provide an unconventional stay on the water. Additionally, if you're willing to travel a bit, nearby towns like Mystic, CT, offer a wider variety of hotels and inns.

Yes, you can travel from Montauk to Fishers Island by bicycle, but it requires a combination of cycling and ferry transportation. You would need to bike to a nearby ferry terminal, such as in New London, CT, which is about 30 miles from Montauk. After taking the ferry to Fishers Island, you can continue exploring the island on your bike. However, be prepared for potential wait times and ensure you have the right gear to make the journey more comfortable.