1map logoGo to main page

Montauk, NY, USA to Shelter Island, NY, USA from $11: 2 ways by bus, train, flight or car

Compare Travel Options and Prices

from
Montauk, United States of America
to
Shelter Island, United States of America

How to Get from Montauk to Shelter Island: Cheapest, Fastest and Best Way

1Map provides directions to cities, towns, landmarks, attractions, and addresses worldwide, offering thousands of multi-modal routes to easily get you from point A to point B.

$11 by busBest price
34 kmDistance
44m Fastest

Compare Train, Bus, Flight, and Driving Options

Get detailed, step-by-step directions below for your trip from Montauk to Shelter Island with 1Map travel planner. Easily compare ticket prices, explore various transport options, and find the best routes for a seamless and cost-effective travel experience.

Company
Long Island Rail Road
Train
Drive
Average Duration
44m
Estimated price
$3-13
Recommended
route map
Distance: 34 km
Duration: 44m

See more options

Company
Hampton Jitney Inc.
Bus
Drive
Average Duration
53m
Estimated price
$11-26
Browse car rentalsExplore flights

Traveling From Montauk to Shelter Island

The journey from Montauk to Shelter Island offers a transition from the vibrant coastal energy of Montauk's beaches to the serene, lush landscapes and quiet charm of Shelter Island.

Best Neighbourhoods in Shelter Island

Shelter Island's neighborhoods offer a variety of experiences for visitors.

Shelter Island Heights
• Scenic views of South Ferries
• Charming historic homes and gardens
Dering Harbor
• Exclusive waterfront properties
• A tranquil, upscale atmosphere
Silver Beach
• Family-friendly beach access
• Vibrant community spirit with local events

Best Times To Visit Shelter Island's Attractions

Maximize your experience by visiting these attractions at the right times.

Mashomack Preserve
Early mornings in spring offer peaceful hiking with blooming flora.
Shelter Island Ferry
Weekdays in late afternoon can provide a quieter, scenic crossing.
Sunset Beach
Arrive before sunset for the best views and fewer crowds.

Shelter Island Weather: What to Expect Year-Round

Shelter Island experiences a temperate climate with warm summers and cool winters, making late spring and early fall the best times to visit for pleasant temperatures. Weather can significantly impact your travel experience, so checking forecasts helps you plan outdoor activities and enjoy all that the island has to offer.

Dining Recommendation in Shelter Island

For an unforgettable experience, try the locally sourced seafood at Vine Street Cafe, where the menu emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients and offers a cozy, rustic atmosphere that contrasts with Montauk's bustling beachside dining. This intimate setting allows you to savor dishes like the vibrant clam chowder or a delicious herb-crusted flounder, showcasing Shelter Island's unique culinary identity.

Montauk - Shelter Island operators

Explore transport companies operating between Montauk and Shelter Island, with prices starting at . These companies offer competitive pricing, flexible schedules, and comfortable travel experiences.

Train
Contact phone
+1-718-217-5477
Website
https://new.mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road

Train from Montauk to East Hampton

Average Duration
24m
Estimated price
$3-13

Train from East Hampton to Shelter Island

Average Duration
20m
Estimated price
$0-0
Bus
Contact phone
+1 212.362.8400
Website
https://www.hamptonjitney.com

Bus from Montauk to Wainscott

Average Duration
35m
Estimated price
$11-26

Bus from Wainscott to Shelter Island

Average Duration
Estimated price
$0-0

Frequently asked questions

Find out more about the route from Montauk to Shelter Island.

Or choose the category:
The distance between Montauk and Shelter Island is 21 miles. The typical travel time by bus from Montauk to Shelter Island is around 1 hour and 30 minutes. Other modes of transportation, such as driving or taking a ferry, may have slightly different travel times.
The best way to travel from Montauk to Shelter Island without a car is by taking a bus and then traveling. This journey usually takes around 53 minutes and the cost will vary depending on the specific bus service you choose. There are different bus options available that can conveniently take you from Montauk to Shelter Island without the need for a private vehicle.
There are plenty of options for accommodation near Shelter Island. With over 155 hotels available in the area, you will have a variety of choices to suit your preferences and budget. Prices start at $90 per night, so you can find a suitable place to stay that fits within your price range. Whether you prefer a luxurious resort or a cozy bed and breakfast, there are accommodations available to meet your needs.
Yes, it is possible to travel from Montauk to Shelter Island by bicycle. The distance between the two locations is approximately miles. The route would take an estimated time of to complete by bike. Please note that the actual travel time may vary depending on factors such as weather conditions and individual cycling speed.