1map logoGo to main page

Islip, NY, USA to Shelter Island, NY, USA from $9: 3 ways by bus, train, flight or car

Compare Travel Options and Prices

from
Islip, United States of America
to
Shelter Island, United States of America

How to Get from Islip to Shelter Island: Cheapest, Fastest and Best Way

1Map provides directions to cities, towns, landmarks, attractions, and addresses worldwide, offering thousands of multi-modal routes to easily get you from point A to point B.

$9 by busBest price
82 kmDistance
1h 45m Fastest

Compare Train, Bus, Flight, and Driving Options

Get detailed, step-by-step directions below for your trip from Islip to Shelter Island with 1Map travel planner. Easily compare ticket prices, explore various transport options, and find the best routes for a seamless and cost-effective travel experience.

Company
Long Island Rail Road
Train
Average Duration
1h  45m
Estimated price
$3-22
Recommended
Company
various
Bus
Bus
Bus
Average Duration
3h  21m
Estimated price
$9-9
Cheapest
route map
Distance: 82 km
Duration: 1h 45m

See more options

Company
Hampton Jitney Inc.
Bus
Average Duration
3h  43m
Estimated price
$18-32
Browse car rentalsExplore flights

Traveling From Islip to Shelter Island

Traveling from Islip to Shelter Island offers you a transition from the vibrant energy of suburban life to the serene charm of an island getaway.

Best Neighbourhoods in Shelter Island

Shelter Island features charming neighborhoods, each with its own character.

Carroll Street
• Scenic waterfront views enhance your experience.
• Close proximity to shops and restaurants.
Shell Beach
• Family-friendly beach ideal for swimming.
• Picturesque hiking trails nearby.
Silver Beach
• Quiet atmosphere perfect for relaxation.
• Gorgeous sunset views each evening.

Best Times To Visit Shelter Island's Attractions

Timing your visits to Shelter Island’s attractions can enhance your experience significantly.

Shelter Island Lighthouse
Early mornings offer stunning views with fewer visitors around.
Mashomack Preserve
Weekdays provide a tranquil hiking experience away from crowds.
Silver Beach
Late afternoons are ideal for relaxing while watching serene sunsets.

Shelter Island Weather: What to Expect Year-Round

Shelter Island experiences a temperate maritime climate, with warm summers and mild winters, making spring and fall the best times for a visit to enjoy pleasant temperatures. Weather can influence your travel experience, so being prepared for occasional rain or wind can enhance your outdoor plans.

Dining Recommendation

At the classic seafood spot, The Pridwin, savor their fresh catch of the day, prepared with local ingredients that embody the island’s coastal charm. This dining experience contrasts sharply with Islip's more suburban fare, offering vibrant flavors and a relaxed atmosphere that invites you to truly enjoy the surrounding beauty.

Islip - Shelter Island operators

Explore transport companies operating between Islip and Shelter Island, with prices starting at . These companies offer competitive pricing, flexible schedules, and comfortable travel experiences.

Train
Contact phone
+1-718-217-5477
Website
https://new.mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road

Train from Islip to Bridgehampton

Average Duration
1h 28m
Estimated price
$3-22
Bus
Contact phone
+1 631.852.5200
Website
http://suffolkbus.com

Bus from Islip Town Hall to Patchogue LIRR

Average Duration
32m
Estimated price
$3-3

Bus from Patchogue LIRR to Riverhead LIRR

Average Duration
1h 18m
Estimated price
$3-3

Bus from Riverhead LIRR to NYS 25/Old Main Rd

Average Duration
37m
Estimated price
$3-3

Bus from Patchogue LIRR to Old Country Rd/Roanoke Ave

Average Duration
1h 24m
Estimated price
$3-3
Contact phone
+1 212.362.8400
Website
https://www.hamptonjitney.com

Bus from Riverhead to Greenport

Average Duration
46m
Estimated price
$13-27

Frequently asked questions

Find out more about the route from Islip to Shelter Island.

Or choose the category:
The distance between Islip and Shelter Island is approximately 51 miles. The typical travel time between the two locations varies depending on the mode of transportation. By train, it takes approximately 1 hour and 45 minutes to reach Shelter Island from Islip. Additional modes of transportation such as driving or taking a ferry may have different travel times, so it is recommended to check for the most up-to-date information.
The most cost-effective and time-efficient transportation option for traveling from Islip to Shelter Island is by train. It takes 1 hour and 45 minutes to reach Shelter Island from Islip by train, and the cost ranges from $3 to $22. Taking the train not only saves time but also offers a reasonable fare compared to other transportation modes. Additionally, it allows passengers to sit back, relax, and enjoy the scenic views along the way.
The prices for a train journey from Islip to Shelter Island can vary from $3 to $22, depending on factors such as time of travel, type of ticket, and any promotions or discounts available. It is recommended to check with the specific train operator for the most accurate and up-to-date pricing information. Additional modes of transportation, such as taxis or private cars, may have different pricing structures, and it is advisable to contact local transportation providers for their rates.
To travel from Islip to Shelter Island without a car, the best option is to take a train. The train journey from Islip to Shelter Island takes approximately 1 hour and 45 minutes. The cost of the train ticket can range between $3 and $22, depending on the specific train service and ticket type. Taking the train is a convenient and affordable way to reach Shelter Island from Islip without a car.
There are plenty of accommodation options near Shelter Island. With over 155 hotels to choose from, visitors have a wide range of choices. Prices start at $90 per night, offering affordable options for travelers on a budget. Whether you prefer a luxury resort, a cozy bed and breakfast, or a convenient motel, there are plenty of options to suit any traveler's needs near Shelter Island.