1map logoGo to main page

New York City, NY, USA to Shelter Island, NY, USA from $3: 3 ways by bus, train, flight or car

Compare Travel Options and Prices

from
New York City, United States of America
to
Shelter Island, United States of America

How to Get from New York City to Shelter Island: Cheapest, Fastest and Best Way

1Map provides directions to cities, towns, landmarks, attractions, and addresses worldwide, offering thousands of multi-modal routes to easily get you from point A to point B.

$3 by trainBest price
144.84 kmDistance
2h 50m Fastest

Compare Train, Bus, Flight, and Driving Options

Get detailed, step-by-step directions below for your trip from New York City to Shelter Island with 1Map travel planner. Easily compare ticket prices, explore various transport options, and find the best routes for a seamless and cost-effective travel experience.

Company
Hampton Jitney Inc.
Bus
Average Duration
2h  50m
Estimated price
$30-50
Recommended
Company
Long Island Rail Road
Train
Average Duration
3h  49m
Estimated price
$3-37
Cheapest
route map
Distance: 144.84 km
Duration: 2h 50m

See more options

Company
Southern Airways Express
Plane
Drive
Average Duration
1h  55m
Estimated price
$55-200
Browse car rentalsExplore flights

Traveling From New York to Shelter Island

The vibrant hustle of New York City transforms into the serene charm of Shelter Island, offering you a refreshing contrast between urban energy and coastal tranquility.

Best Neighbourhoods in Shelter Island

Shelter Island's neighborhoods offer diverse experiences for all visitors.

Silver Beach
• Stunning waterfront views with beautiful sandy beaches.
• Close-knit community with a friendly atmosphere.
Dering Harbor
• Upscale homes with luxurious amenities and privacy.
• Ideal for boating enthusiasts with easy access to marinas.
Shelter Island Heights
• Charming historic architecture and picturesque landscapes.
• Popular spot for art galleries and local shops.

Best Times To Visit Shelter Island's Attractions

Planning your trip to Shelter Island? Consider these tips for the best experiences.

Mashomack Preserve
Visit early mornings or weekdays for peaceful hiking trails and fewer visitors.
Shelter Island Historical Society
Explore on weekdays for a quieter experience while enjoying the exhibits.
Cocktail Bars in the Heights
Evenings during the shoulder seasons offer a laid-back vibe and great sunset views.

Shelter Island Weather: What to Expect Year-Round

Shelter Island enjoys a coastal temperate climate with warm summers and mild winters, making late spring to early fall an ideal time for outdoor activities. Be mindful that weather conditions can influence your plans, from beach days in summer to cozy winter escapes.

Dining Recommendation in Shelter Island

Try the clam chowder at The Pridwin, which showcases the fresh, local seafood that defines the island's culinary scene; it's a taste of New England charm amid a relaxed atmosphere. This contrasts with the fast-paced dining of New York, allowing you to savor every mouthful while enjoying the stunning waterfront views.

New York City - Shelter Island operators

Explore transport companies operating between New York City and Shelter Island, with prices starting at . These companies offer competitive pricing, flexible schedules, and comfortable travel experiences.

Bus Show bus routes
Contact phone
+1 212.362.8400
Website
https://www.hamptonjitney.com

Bus from Cadman Pz W/Clark St to Greenport

Average Duration
2h 46m
Estimated price
$30-50
Train Show train routes
Contact phone
+1-718-217-5477
Website
https://new.mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road

Train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkoma

Average Duration
1h 21m
Estimated price
$3-22

Train from Ronkonkoma to Greenport

Average Duration
1h 24m
Estimated price
$0-15
Plane Show flights
Website
http://iflysouthern.com

Plane from New York Skyports Seaplane Base (NYS) to Bridgeport (BDR)

Average Duration
35m
Estimated price
$55-200

New York City to Shelter Island: Overview of Bus, Train, Flight, and Car Trips

Traveling between New York City and Shelter Island offers a variety of convenient options to suit your preferences, schedule, and budget. Whether you prioritize affordability, speed, or comfort, you’re sure to find the perfect way to travel without compromising on quality or convenience.

🚆 Embark on a scenic train journey from New York City to Shelter Island, enjoying a travel time of 3 hours and 49 minutes. Sit back, relax, and take in the beautiful views along the way. 💸 Ticket prices for the train between New York and Shelter Island are quite reasonable, ranging from $3 to $37. Whether you're looking for a budget-friendly option or a more comfortable ride, there are various fare choices to suit your needs.
Useful tips for train travellers
• For your train journey from New York City to Shelter Island, consider using the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) as the main operator. Onboard, LIRR offers a catering service that provides light snacks, coffee, and beverages, which can enhance your travel experience. However, be aware that options may be limited on some off-peak trains, so consider bringing your own refreshments.
• The LIRR offers various seating options including Standard (Economy), First Class, and Business Class. First Class boasts more spacious seating, complimentary drinks and snacks, and quieter environments, making it a perfect choice for a more relaxed trip. For the average traveler, Standard Class is usually fine, but depending on your schedule, booking a First Class seat in advance can enhance your journey.
• After arriving at Shelter Island, you won’t find a traditional train station, but you can take the LIRR to Greenport and then transfer to a ferry service to Shelter Island. A helpful resource is the North Ferry website (northferry.com), which provides schedules and information on ferry services. Keep in mind that once you arrive at Shelter Island, you won't have luggage storage facilities; plan to carry all your belongings with you or arrange accommodations nearby. For transport to various parts of the island, local taxis are available, but the best way to explore is by renting a bike or using local shuttle services.
🛫 Experience a convenient and quick travel option from New York to Shelter Island by taking a direct flight from New York Skyports Seaplane Base Airport to Bridgeport Airport. This short flight will only take you around 35 minutes with Southern Airways Express.
Departure Point
New York Skyports Seaplane Base Airport
Arrival Point
Bridgeport Airport
The journey typically takes around 2 hours and 50 minutes, allowing you to enjoy the scenic ride.

Frequently asked questions

Find out more about the route from New York City to Shelter Island.

Or choose the category:
The distance between New York and Shelter Island is approximately 90 miles. The typical travel times by various modes of transportation are as follows: 2 hours and 17 minutes by train, 1 hour and 56 minutes by flying then traveling, and 2 hours and 50 minutes by bus. These times may vary depending on traffic, weather conditions, and other factors. It is always recommended to check for the most up-to-date schedules and routes before planning your trip.
The most cost-effective and time-efficient transportation option for traveling from New York to Shelter Island is by train. It takes approximately 2 hours and 17 minutes and costs between $3 and $40. This is both the cheapest and quickest way to reach Shelter Island from New York. Other modes of transportation such as flying or taking a bus may be more expensive or time-consuming.
The prices for a train ticket between New York and Shelter Island range from $3 to $40, depending on the type of ticket and the time of travel. On the other hand, the prices for a bus ticket between Shelter Island and New York can vary from $30 to $50, also depending on the type of ticket and the time of travel. It is important to note that prices may fluctuate, so it is advisable to check with the respective transportation providers for the most accurate and up-to-date prices.
The best way to travel from New York to Shelter Island without a car is by train. The train journey takes approximately 2 hours and 17 minutes and costs between $3 and $40, depending on the specific route and time of travel. Taking the train allows you to relax and enjoy the scenic journey to Shelter Island.
The flight between New York and Shelter Island typically takes 36 minutes on a direct flight from New York Skyports Seaplane Base Airport to Bridgeport Airport. As for the cost, it would depend on the airline and the time of booking. Prices can vary, but a round-trip ticket can range from $200 to $400. It's always recommended to check with different airlines for the most up-to-date pricing information.
There are several options for accommodations near Shelter Island. With over 155 hotels available, you are sure to find something that suits your needs and budget. Prices start at $90 per night, offering a range of choices to fit various budgets. Whether you prefer waterfront resorts, cozy bed and breakfasts, or budget-friendly motels, there are plenty of options available for a comfortable stay near Shelter Island.

Trips from New York City